Illinois Guy | Date: Jan 08, 2011:

My one and only swinging experience didn’t go very well.  It was about three years ago.  My wife Peggy was reluctant to begin with, she is overweight and very self conscious.  She put up so many conditions that it was hard to find a couple that she was willing to meet.  I found Gary and Sherry from Elgin on a swinger site and we setup a meeting to have drinks.  They looked like average people, close to our age and inexperienced like we were.  After a couple of drinks everyone agreed they were ready to swap so we went to a motel and got adjoining rooms.  Sherry turned out to be a screamer and made a lot of noise when I fucked her.  She was a great fuck.  I never gave a thought to what was going on in the other room but looked forward to hearing about it later.  Peggy and Gary seemed a little subdued when we said goodbye.  As soon we were in our car, Peggy started complaining that Gary didn’t like her.  She said he couldn’t get an erection and they spent the hour just talking.  She said they could hear us like we were in the same room and glad at least one of us had a good time, but she wasn’t interested in doing it again.